Pretty Gay (2024)
A comedic unscripted web series hosted by Catherine McCafferty in which she goes on "first dates" with other queer comics, Pretty Gay gives audiences a glimpse into what flirting could be like if it happened on a set designed to look like a gay bar.
Trailer
Cast
Seasons
Season 1
E1 Anna Garcia
Catherine sits down with actress and comedian Anna Garcia to, among other things, hatch the world's worst karaoke song.
E2 Ellory Smith
Join Catherine as she attempts to woo comedian and writer Ellory Smith on this week's episode of Pretty Gay. Her opinions and inherent charm are dazzling.
E3 Sarah Schauer
Enjoy the wonderful comedy stylings of Sarah Schauer on this episode of Pretty Gay. Join Catherine for lots of laughs and one very informative moment about how to pick up women at a bar.
E4 Pallavi Gunalan
Catherine dates comedian Pallavi Gunalan. Discussion points: coming out of the closet, the appropriate amount of ransom, and who keeps the dildo in the divorce. Featuring a mom and even a dad!
E5 Hannah Pilkes
Catherine welcomes the silly sexy stylings of Hannah Pilkes. Delight at the wonders of uncanny impressions, reading each other's minds and singing what can only be called a very original song.
E6 Yazmin Monet Watkins
Yazmin Monet Watkins dazzles us this week at Pretty Gay. Catherine McCafferty may have every single red flag Yazmin name but that won't stop our host from trying to win Yazmin over with jokes, astrology, and far too many thumbs' ups.
Season 2
E1 Vic Michaelis
The Pretty Gay Season 2 premiere! Catherine McCafferty welcomes the incredibly funny Vic Michaelis. Is Catherine off the market now?!
E2 Lorena Russi
Sparks fly as Catherine confuses, flirts, and falls in love with fantastic soccer player turned comedian Lorena Russi.
E3 Jordan Myrick
Catherine may have colitis and Jordan Myrick may be a bit of a chef, but that won't stop these two from falling in love.
E4 Grant O'Brien
Catherine sits down with comedian and on-screen bartender Grant O'Brien for what can only be described as a very bisexual date.
E5 Jiavani
Watch Catherine fall in love with the supremely talented comedian, improviser, and Dalmatian Jiavani.
E6 Anna Garcia (2)
Anna Garcia is back for a second date. It’s fun, it’s spicy, dare we say she flies Catherine’s heart straight to the moon?
E7 Angela Giarratana
Catherine sits down with comedian and internet sensation Angela Giarratana as the two of them hard launch their new relationship on Instagram.
E8 Erika Ishii
Happy HoliGay! This week Catherine goes on a date with the hilarious voice actor, host, and D20 star Erika Ishii! There are swords, snakes, and a brief PSA to Vin Diesel.
E9 Rachel Scanlon
Comedian and very tall person Rachel Scanlon joins us on this spicy episode filled with Veggie Tales, bull riding, and lots of flirty eye contact!
E10 Maddie Zahm
Singer and all-around sweetie Maddie Zahm sits down to date Catherine on this anxiously attached episode of Pretty Gay! Pre-save Maddie's new single Sheets if you like sapphic love songs and you know you do!
E11 Bri Giger
Comedian, actress, and DJ Bri Giger joins Catherine on this week's date! Watch them flirt with snacks, discuss kinks, and uncover an unlikely bond over mayonnaise.
E12 Kendahl Landreth
The absolutely hilarious comedian and content superstar Kendahl Landreth joins Catherine on this week's Pretty Gay. They laugh, they flirt, they talk about having dead dads- classic first date stuff. Check out Kendahl's podcast with former guest and her future wife Jordan Myrick called Happy Wife Happy Life!
E13 Harper-Rose Drummond
Please enjoy actress and comedian Harper-Rose as she takes Catherine on a wild date filled with giggles, trauma bonding, and a tough game of What's the Gayest?
E14 Alex Song-Xia
Watch Catherine fall in love with comedian, actor, and writer Alex Song-Xia over a particularly spicy game of role-play!
E15 Pallavi Gunalan (2)
Welcoming back: the extraordinary Pallavi Gunalan for our Season 2 Finale!! Watch as they create discourse, learn about each other's exes, and ultimately hard launch ON MAIN. Follow Pallavi Gunalan on socials for their stand-up dates and projects!
Season 3
E1 Angela Giarratana (2)
ANGELA RETURNS to open Season 3 of Pretty Gay with a bang! It's giving gown, it's giving engagement, it's giving...milk?
E2 Demi Burnett
TV Personality Demi Burnett woos Catherine with her impressive improv, fun anecdotes, and a dazzling first KISS!
E3 Kimia Behpoornia
The delightfully hilarious improvisor and actor Kimia Behpoornia dazzles on this week's date of Pretty Gay. Impressions, confessions, and dare we say a little smooch is in store!!
E4 Liv Hewson
You may have seen them on Yellowjackets and now here on Pretty Gay?! The very talented, entirely too delightful Liv Hewson dates Catherine on this week's episode. Watch as these two redheads flirt, HARD LAUNCH, break up, and play a fun game of would-you-rather.
E5 Cameron Esposito
Comedian and actor Cameron Esposito joins this date with the charisma of a sexy cartoon fox. Introducing the one and only Margaret Fitzpatrick, starring in the segment "Meet My Mom!" And it wouldn't be Cameron Esposito without some grade A push-ups!
E6 Persephone Valentine
You may know her from numerous shows on Drop Out, most notably D20; Pretty Gay was thrilled to have Persephone on this very fun, absolutely giggly, date!
E7 Vanessa Papa
You might've caught her on the first season of The Queer Ultimatum, and spoiler alert: she isn't engaged; instead, she is dating me! Watch this fun, flirty episode for lols, lip biting, and maybe someone even gets physically picked up (again)!
E8 Hannah Pilkes (2)
Hannah Pilkes returns for a SECOND DATE! You may have seen this superstar on the new Netflix series Leanne, or performing live in your city- either way, if you've met her once, you're in love, so just imagine dating her twice, does to Catherine... it may or may not make her speak in a bad British accent...more than once!
E9 Madison Sinclair
This week, Catherine falls in love with the very funny comedian Madison Sinclair. These two cover exes trying to break no contact via VENMO, housekeeper nudes, and the most romantic date... Sept 11th? Giggle along, tell your friends, show your mom!
E10 Gracin
This week, Pretty Gay have funny online and funny in person, Gracin on our date! Watch as Catherine and her potential new gf awkward pause, bond over moving slow, and sexy diarrhea descriptions.
E11 Jade Catta-Preta
You may have seen this gorgeous guest performing stand-up or gracing your tv screens! Jade and Catherine teeheehee about flirting, rapping, and being Brazilian (well... one of them laughs about being Brazilian, the other is painfully Irish). Enjoy as these two funny women fall in love, or at least talk about it.
E12 E.R. Fightmaster
This week, we have the absolutely charming E.R. Fightmaster, an actor, a musician, an audio p0*n star... You gotta watch it to see it. E.R. meets Catherine's mom, saves Catherine from choking, and gives the most creative present to date!
E13 Ginger Gonzaga
You might recognize this circus mouse from the many dazzling TV and movies she appears in, or perhaps you've seen her on your local Gondola... it is Ginger Gonzaga!! Watch Catherine stuff her face with marshmallows, unload a traumatic story as a joke, and possibly even fall in love! This date is brought to you by Big Sparkle- don't forget to shine this Halloween with Big Sparkle.
E14 Allison Reese
You might know her for her iconic Kamala impression or hilarious improv; we have Allison Reese dazzling our screens this week. Watch as Catherine and Allison talk dirty in spin class, hard launch, and discover they are both really good at flirting!
E15 Shannon Beveridge
A self-identified Shane trying to be a Dana, Shannon Beveridge joins Catherine to flirt, kiss, and maybe even meet her mom!!!
E16 Irene Tu
Funerals, dating multiple people at once, and falling down elevator shafts... Another classic first date with the fantastic and hilarious stand-up Irene Tu!
E17 Madi Hart
Welcome the absolute girl's girl Madi Hart into your homes and you'll instantly fall in love! A charming, funny, and kissable date!
E18 D.J. Mausner
Join the crew in closing out 2025 with the hilarious improvisor and writer D.J. Mausner! They talk about dating with dead dads, trying to appeal to the male gaze, and ultimately being pretty GAY!
E19 Ruha Taslimi
This week, we go on a date with the very funny improviser Ruha Taslimi, watch as they charm Catherine, talk about light stalking, spiders, and non-monogamy.
E20 Anna Garcia (3)
This finale wraps up season 3 with the one and only girl who was with Pretty Gay since day one. Bringing onto the show her silly wit and charming personality, will these two actually kiss this time? Is there fairy smut? Does Anna meet mom?
Season 4
E1 Vic Michaelis (2)
The one and only famous host, honorary president of Dropout and star of Ponies on Peacock opens the season with a date that starts with a near break-up!
E2 Leandra Earl
LESBIAN OF THE YEAR LEANDRA EARL FROM THE BAND THE BEACHES?? Are you kidding me? Watch these two flirt, bump teeth, and play... coffin?
E3 Anna Akana
The hilarious and talented Anna Akana learns a lot she doesn't love about Catherine on this week's date of Pretty Gay. Will Catherine turn it around, or is her fate written in the stars?
E4 Vivian Wilson
Our first professional model to grace the Pretty Gay set Miss Vivian Wilson stuns with wit and looks. We laugh, we get read, we ... offend people with a sock puppet?
E5 Madi Webb
ARE YOU KIDDING ME? This episode with fashion girly/podcaster/creator Madi Webb is spicy, so strap on and strap up because we are about to start rumors.
E6 Bridget Matloff
You may know her from the Queer Ultimatum, but I know her from the show we run at Nico's, and of course, this epic date!! Bridget liked getting engaged on camera so much that she may have done it twice!
E7 Sabrina Jalees
Recently, a writer on Mating, now out on Netflix, this comedian absolutely dominates the date!!! DO THEY KISS THROUGH A PIECE OF PAPER? You better believe it! I dare you not to fall in love with the charm of the one and only Sabrina Jalees.
E8 Casey Tanner
THE Queer Sex Therapist Casey Tanner is joining us for a tickling and insightful date! Casey Tanner answers your burning questions, like what is the gayest kind of breakup, friend or romantic? A longer episode because we simply couldn't cut anything!
E9 E.R. Fightmaster
It is our 50th episode of Pretty Gay!!! We thought we would bring back a crowd (and a personal) favorite E.R. FIGHTMASTER!!!
E10 Mo Welch
You can watch her on the Paper or in Office Romance on Netflix, or maybe you read her comic, Blair, either way, she is with us on Pretty Gay, batting her eyes and slinging her jokes! A gorgeous, hilarious date for the books.
E11 Anna Garcia (4)
Welcome back, back, back AGAIN Anna Garcia. Our only fourth-time dater. We get right into the hard questions- which chair will she choose? How will they break up... and does Anna give Catherine a gift she will keep close to her foot forever?
E12 Kathryn Gallagher
The extremely talented and effervescent Kathryn Gallagher joins us for a spectacular and adorable date... TWO CATHERINES? Lucky you!
E13 Deison Afualo
Lucky number 13! The crossover you definitely knew you needed- it's the funniest sweetheart, Deison Afualo. We flirt, we laugh, we do this all in front of a mom and a sister, what is there not to love?
E14 Hannah Pilkes (3)
Welcome back, back, back again, the hilarious comedian and actor Hannah Pilkes. We are giggling and goofing from the first second, so buckle up for a bananas time that may or may not include my mom teaching Hannah how to flirt!
E15 Shanel Hughes
Shanel Hughes is a very funny comedian who recently moved from Denver to LA to make all the girls fall in love! Watch us giggle, kiss, and break up at my own sister's wedding.
E16 Gatlin
"What if I love you way too much..." is what I listened to on repeat during a big breakup in 2022, and now I get to date the singer! Fall in love, laugh, and heal yourself from religious trauma (but seriously TW we do talk about some weird church group stuff)!
E17 Rivkah Reyes
Welcoming a musician since childhood and a diva since birth, RIVKAH REYES! Watch, share with your friends, and make sure to check out Rivkah's new music, bound to make you fall in love, cry, and dance.
E18 Emeline
Welcoming to the stage a rockstar, a Leo, and in her own words, "just a girl," Emeline! Stream her music after you watch her woo her way into Catherine, kissing her neck, and that's just in the first 5 minutes.
E19 Syd Heller
This episode has so many silly, laugh-out-loud moments that it will be impossible not to fall head over heels for our hilarious guest comedian and host of her own podcast, Syd Heller! Enjoy our antics, and I promise I know what a geyser is.
E20 Jiavani (2)
Welcome back to the date improvisor, actor, and all-around wonderful human Jiavani! Will we dance? Will we talk about threesomes? Will we lock the heck in?
Similar
Lookism
Game Grumps
The Ellen DeGeneres Show
How Dare You!?
OverFeed
Valoran Town
My Page in the 90s
TV Heaven, Telly Hell
De Schuur van Scheire
Game Changer
2Wish
Give You My Heart
Where to Watch
Not currently streaming in the US
Streaming data by JustWatch